Pair / Group
Distinguishing Feature
German vs Brown-banded
Both about 1/2 inch. German: TWO STRIPES on pronotum; egg cases CARRIED until day before hatching; loves kitchens with sink traps. Brown-banded: pronotum has light side margins (NO stripes); LIGHT BANDS across body and wings; egg cases GLUED in clumps; flourishes in WARM apartments; favors high cabinets and warm motors (TVs, clocks).
American vs Oriental
Both large, both called "waterbug." American: 1 1/3 to 1 1/2 in; reddish-brown; light yellow pronotum margin; both sexes WINGED; lives in warm moist places (boiler rooms, decaying trees). Oriental: 1 to 1 1/4 in; very dark brown/black; female WINGLESS; ONE generation/year; tolerates cooler temps; crawl spaces, foundations, floor drains.
Brown vs Smoky brown vs American (all Periplaneta)
American: light yellow pronotum margin; slender pointed cerci. Brown: lacks light pronotum coloration; cerci wider with blunt tips; transported in plant soil; sewers/crawl spaces. Smoky brown: dark mahogany; NO light markings on pronotum or wings; gutters, roof shingles, attics; very moisture-dependent.
Australian vs Brown vs Surinam (all plant-associated)
Australian: looks like American but with conspicuous LIGHT-YELLOW pronotum margins; introduced on tropical interior plants. Brown: transported in plant soil; sewers/crawl spaces/garages. Surinam: ALL FEMALES in US; hitchhikes in plant soil.
Woods vs Asian (outdoor)
Woods: lives in rotted logs, tree stumps, firewood; males fly to lights; ONCE INDOORS THEY DIE; no pesticide needed. Asian: looks IDENTICAL to German but lives outdoors; attracted to light (unlike most roaches); brought to MI by travelers from southern states.
Aggregation pheromone vs Sex pheromone
Aggregation pheromone: short-range odor that holds adults + larger nymphs together in harborage; facilitates mating by keeping sexes proximal. Sex pheromone: females release to attract males for mating; American cockroach sex pheromone is available commercially for traps.
What CAUSES cockroaches to leave favorable harborage
All of these: population pressure, intensive cleaning, pesticide applications, reduction of temperature/humidity. They don't leave easily — only negative changes drive migration.