Pair / Group
Distinguishing Feature
Specific vs Broad-spectrum
Specific: effective against certain insects or stages — usually less toxic to humans/non-targets. Broad-spectrum: toxic to the target pest AND a wide range of similar organisms — greater non-target effects.
Toxicity vs Risk
Toxicity: inherent capacity to cause harm. Risk: function of toxicity AND exposure. Reducing exposure (rapid breakdown, low rates, application to non-drinking water) reduces risk even with toxic compounds.
Bti vs Bs
Both microbial bacteria, both registered larvicides, both bind to insect-gut receptor cells (not in mammals), both must be INGESTED. Bti: registered 1983; broadly used. Bs: registered 1991; especially good in richly organic systems (Culex).
Bti vs Spinosad
Both produced by bacteria. Bti: requires ingestion of bacterial cells; gut-disruption MOA. Spinosad (Natular): does NOT require ingestion of bacterial cells; affects nervous system. Spinosad has wider habitat applicability including stormwater catch basins.
Temephos vs other organophosphates
Temephos: the ONLY OP approved as a LARVICIDE; resistance management tool; WHO-approved for potable water; more toxic to aquatic invertebrates than alternatives. Malathion / Chlorpyrifos / Naled: OP ADULTICIDES.
Monomolecular films vs Larviciding oils
Both form a surface barrier on water; both affect larvae/pupae. Films: surfactants reduce surface tension — larvae/pupae/emerging adults can't attach and drown. Oils: petroleum distillates physically clog breathing tubes. Oils may be toxic to fish if misapplied.
Pyrethrins vs Pyrethroids vs PBO
Pyrethrins: natural compounds from chrysanthemum flowers. Pyrethroids (permethrin, resmethrin, sumithrin): synthetic chemicals modeled on pyrethrins. PBO (piperonyl butoxide): synergist mixed with pyrethroids — enhances effectiveness; not an insecticide itself.